Regarding the question about how the “economy and production” should be managed to serve the communes best: In my opinion, I don’t think anarchism could work on a huge scale. The communes would have to be very small. This way the people in the community know eachother and what they need. To go on a larger scale would be too chaotic for a group of people to keep track of everything.
Dominic () - 27 10 08 - 14:40

Q1. Global Anarchy. We can’t just have an anarchist area. Governments would attempt to take that area over. If somebody tried to create a government in an anarchist society, it would be stopped.
Q2. I wouldn’t stop counter revolution unless it infringed upon me, like the creation of a government.
Q3. As an anarchist, I don’t set out to stop people from speaking their thoughts (propagandising their ideology). I mean to change (through education, not forcing my ideas) conformed people into people who see that they don’t have to change their thoughts and actions because it’s what the rest of the people are doing.
Q3. (Part Two) Wouldn’t the communities know what they need better than some large corporation? I would think so.
Q4. I’ve seen quick military decisions made. THAT LEADS TO MORE QUICK MILITARY DECISIONS. Maybe we won’t make a quick decision, but we’ll sure as hell make the right one. AND! If the commune is small enough, direct democracy may actually be possible. Also, refer back to Q1.
Q5. We don’t have to follow an anarchists leaders’ orders like we have to with governmental figures.
Q6. Who said anything about no hiearchy in the workplace?
Q7. I don’t riot against the police when they’re not being corrupt. Don’t assume all anarchists do.
Q8. Participation in the parliament? WTH is that? Like British voting? Well, I live in America and I don’t vote because it does not determine the outcome of the election. Our elections are decided by the Electoral College. You’d be surprised how many American’s don’t know that.
Q9. In the world’s history, all communist areas have had a government. I think that would be a difference between communism and anarchy. However, I’m defining communism by what it HAS been, not by what it should be.
Violence is never necessary.
[Kaleb] () - 28 10 08 - 12:58

Interesting video. Good question; bad manners.
I’m not sure whether he was trying to argue from his views or the media’s. Either way, he is still misled.
I do not attack the law enforcement, I simply ignore their attempts at establishing peace.
He has unfairly generalized us.
The Spectator () (URL) - 30 10 08 - 17:55

I think the questions are a bit “outside” of anarchy. We’d still have bosses where we work, councils for “laws” and “morals.” people so often forget that anarchy is not chaos, but a set standard of rules decided on from the people. If another region attacks, couldn’t the people fight back?

And yes….very bad manners….another high school/college student trying to make a point without knowing all the facts.
Ty - 04 11 08 - 13:26

Good questions, i congrat you for this post
Q1: imagine a regular army that receives an emboscade from the enemy, who quickly identify the leader and kill him, I don’t think that the squad should sourrender and I don’t think they will have enough time to choose a new leader… they must organize themselves as they can, apply comradery principle that means sacrifice oneself for another,
if on that situation a non anarchist squad can organize a self defense without a leader, why should an anarchist group should not do that?
Q2: anarchism means freedom, equality and fraternity and of course non-authoritarianism. so, anarchism is not a rigid though, any ideology should be accepted and, without violent manners if it is wrong it should be tried to be correctet by reason education (no brainwash, no torture…) and why not to learn from it if that though have productive elements
the CR one should be:
a. the one(s) who tries to establish any way of government in the organization
b. the one(s) who don’t do anything productive to the group and want to live by the work of the rest ones
c. the adulator(s)
Q3: answer; federations. Global anarchism working in a descentralized form (each community should have their own problems, apart of the general problems)
Q4: answered in Q2
Q5: we should not need extraordinary material conditions, but a minimum necessary should be reached by (a) clandestine economy, (b) taking property off the hands of exploiters and/or white neck thieves and put it at administration and serve to all the comunity. FREEDOM OVER EFFICIENCE
Q6: direct democracy, huge debate and constant anarchist-like co-education (i add these two last points because there are cases when people don’t know clearly what do they want or what do they need)

about syndicalism: in real life syndicates use to ask for limosnes from the state, or by deffect from capitalists, and them use to have their leader(s)

anarchism is bult over the base of individual/collective freedom, communism does not consider freedom (just in the speech) and it keeps the superstructure built during the ‘proletariat’ dictatorship (marxism teaches that the state should be irrelevant (?) not that it dissapears)

on the road to communism though by marxism, i don’t understand how does a superstructure built over the masses “on their service” with almost absolute power, having abolishing all disicence and social classes will magically evaporate?. That’s why i am not a communist

For me, violence is not necesary but in a close future violence should be unnavoidable cuz i don’t thing that the ones who hold power should leave it voluntarialy without possibility to retake it.

I have an additional question.
what happens if a bad member of an anarchist organization is very respected at the group
(maybe because everyone things that the group has not a good image at the eyes of the society because of external propaganda, but not because of the actions of that unescrupulous member who receives money from child proxenets or drugs trafficers as the result of pacts with them or who attack innocent people during the riots)? how can the other members of the organization take notice of his behavior without falling on the temptation of missthrust and vigilate each others?
sorry if my question is too long, i am making an effort to ask it clearly.
Thanks,
Meurssault
Meurssault - 30 11 08 - 03:46

http://www.shoesmbts.com MBT shoes People are out and about all the time, in various different places and different environments. Finding shoes that are comfortable and funtional in every estting is hard to find. [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/]MBT shoes[/url][/b] have a lot of different styles. [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/]MBT 2010[/url][/b] has both a new men’s and women’s line that lends to a variety of shoe styles for any person. http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-maliza-shoe.. MBT maliza shoes [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-maliza-shoes-c-12.html]MBT maliza shoes[/url][/b] can be worn with a lot of different outfits so as to give a man options when dealing with different situations and outings. Any pair of [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-maliza-shoes-c-12.html]MBT shoes sale[/url][/b] that a woman is looking for, Finding a pair of sandals that will befit taking kids on an outing. While a woman loves to have the diversity of many different shoes in her wardrobe, for a day to day setting, can be found in [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/]MBT[/url][/b] collection. Bought a MBT sheos when http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-mwalk-shoes.. MBT shoes clearance[b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-mwalk-shoes-c-1.html]MBT shoes clearance[/url][/b] is key to looking good and having those around you know that you take care of yourself. [b][url=http://www.shoesmbts.com/mbt-mwalk-shoes-c-1.html]MBT Shoes uk[/url][/b] really do make a person and when you are wearing the right pair for the right situation, it will make all the difference.
mbt shoes () (URL) - 10 05 10 - 18:50

Perfect ghd straighteners online sell, many kinds of ghd flat iron provided.http://www.ghdoutlet-au.com
ghd straighteners () (URL) - 11 05 10 - 02:28

http://www.clothshoe.com :Bikini designer swimwear including Ed Hardy swimwear and bikinis, one piece sexy girl bikini, seperate bikini tops and bottons , plus size sexy swimwear bikini,and maternity swimwear, to kaftans, cover ups and summer dresses, beach hats and cheap MBT shoes. At Simply Beach you’ll find everything you need to complete your summer wardrobe. With the latest collections from some of the biggest ralph lauren bikini designers including Banana Moon, Melissa Odabash, Seafolly, Freya, Fantasie, Aguaclara, womens mbt , Sun seeker, Miracle suit. aspx Miracle suit, Salinas, Vix and Phax. And new for 2010 were adding Panache bikinis and swimwear. Along with Baku and Ginja – two of Australia top chanel swimwear online brands, Gottex and Silver by Gottex? MBT on sale Israeli swimwear and sexy bikinis sale designer renown for high fashion swimwear and bold statement pieces. Whether youre looking for a striking print to wow on the beach or separates in solid colors to mix and match, we’ve got a huge range of sizes, colors , prints, styles and fit everyone’s buy coach swimsuits needs. Whoever you are, you can look beach beautiful in lacoste bikini sale from Simply Beach! Some guests said: I love the last two pair of womens MBT shoes that I purchased from clothshoe, and I love ordering from clothshoe,Inc because they have such fast and speedy delivery. My MBT sport shoes are so comfortable and they rock. http://www.clothshoe.com/
sexy bikini sale () (URL) - 11 05 10 - 20:23

thanks for your share!
p90x () (URL) - 20 05 10 - 01:30

coach you will find the best coach handbags. buy
discount coach handbags at our website.
coach handbags.
coach handbags () (URL) - 27 05 10 - 17:42

we sale coach handbags worldwide. discount coach can be got, coach handbags is top quality
coach handbags () (URL) - 27 05 10 - 17:45

Birkenstock was Made in Germany since 1774 . Check out our Birkenstock sandals and Birkenstock shoes including the Birkenstock gizeh,at the lowest regular outlet prices, free shipping and when you put on Birkenstocks. you will feel very comfortable.
birkenstock () (URL) - 03 06 10 - 01:59

Not only will this MBT Shoes provide a positive effect on your entire body, it will also complement any casual outfit. Go with shoes by MBT Now! MBT Changa guarantee good quality & good service. Come to pick one you love! Many people wear the MBT Shuguli GTX Men’s Shoes for taking off weight actually. Vibram Five Fingers fasten the instep strap before latching the heel straps. This will guarantee the foot is positioned properly. http://www.mbts-mbtshoes.com/
mbt shoes () (URL) - 19 06 10 - 00:25

[url=http://www.shinyawl.com]cartier jewelry[/url] for the birthday gift? [url=http://www.linksvip.uk.com]links of london jewellery[/url] Is the better way to service ur purpose I think. I don’t recommended [url=http://www.shinyawl.com]cartier jewelry[/url] for the reason that the 2nd jewellery is more famous than it. Or what about [url=http://www.yofollow.com]nfl jerseys[/url]? I mean u can do it for her bro~uh..just a joke, I think follow the [url=http://www.mbtag.com]mbt shoes[/url] tips can work out the whole thing. So, see u next time, wishes that I can see ur [url=http://www.linksvip.uk.com]links of london jewellery[/url] next time! Cy!
[andy0000] (URL) - 28 07 10 - 20:43

Do u like nike shoes? No? so you r not a sport fun..what about the tiffany jewellery, Gucci handbags and Louis vuitton handbags? I think u’d like one of them if u like fashion much. Our site have different kinds of guides for the nike shoes, Gucci handbags and so on, especially tiffany jewellery and Louis vuitton handbags, if you need a pair of nike shoes, check our guides first, you may got your need! Cy!
[andy0000] (URL) - 28 07 10 - 20:47

I have read a article today on uggs. Now not only coach handbags I want to sell but also ugg boots. You now ugg boots has a lot of consumers due to the weather. I used to watch the TV of korean play- sorry, I love you. I am so moved and at that time I do not know that the character carries coach handbags and wears ugg boots. I am so shocked. So soon I will won more than one factory coach outlet store
Welcome to visit factory coach outlet store: http://www.factorycoachoutlet.com/
factory coach outlet () (URL) - 29 07 10 - 23:38

Life stories of some men make one ugg boots cheap succumb to their ingenuity. Some people have proved and some are proving without a second cheap ugg boot store doubt that they are winners. Anybody,uggs on sale in uk who has read “A Beautiful Mind” or has watched a movie by the same name, can never remain untouched by the courage of a sundance tall ugg schizophrenic Prof. Nash who overcame the disease by merely accepting the haunting illusions and getting the uggs sundance coveted Noble prize for game theory. Political ugg classic tall boots leaders, Writers, Economist, Musicians and Sportsmen have been a beacon to their uggs classic tall fellowmen.It is from Act II Scene I Duke Senior, the banished duke says about uggs bailey button boots Sweet uses of adversity.To quote a part of it “Sweet are the uses of adversity, Which, like the toad, ugly and venomous, Wears yet a precious jewel in his bailey uggs uk head; And this our life exempt from public haunt Finds tongues in ugg argyle knit sale trees, books in the running cheap argyle uggs brooks, Sermons in stones and good in every thing.This approach closely follows the ugg classic cardy boots white cheap philosophical approach with a beauty of its own. To appreciate the beauty of life one can relish the works of artists and writers of renaissance period. Be it Da Vinci with the ethereal Mona Lisa, Rembrandt or Monet with classic cardy Water Lillies brought out the essence of life. http://www.uggsbailey.co.uk/sitemap.html clz
ugg boots cheap () (URL) - 08 08 10 - 00:39

Now 2010, vibram five fingers shoes shoes have been popular in the world. The traditional air cushion sports shoes have always been to protect the feet and ankles and athletes must have product. However, in 2009, a new type of rubber "five finger shoes" are quietly launched a campaign world "revolution" five fingers vibram now in the vibrambazaar.com all in the fashion design line. In the fashion hot you can also choice five finger shoesmore chance for you.
[andy0000] () (URL) - 13 08 10 - 19:53

Nelly charts in the spring of 2000, and in gucci shoes turn, became a best-selling air jordan shoes rappers air jordans for sale in game.Nelly has become a major player in the music industry in a few years with more than 40 million discs sold worldwide.
jordan shoes () (URL) - 07 09 10 - 23:12